Does Design Affect Community Engagement?

Had an interesting thought/conversation/question yesterday. Does designing a blog to look different than most blogs affect the level of engagement (i.e. number and quality of comments) on that blog? I’m not talking about the quality of a site’s design but more it’s similarity to other blog designs.

Blogs tend to look and feel a certain way. They have a post section on the left and a sidebar or two on the right. They look a lot like this blog. When you’re on a blog, you typically know it.

To restate: Does designing a blog that doesn’t look like a blog affect, either negatively or positively, the reader’s propensity to comment? For example, if a blog looks like this:

ncc-website

Is the reader more, less, or equally likely to comment as he or she would be were the same comment to be on a blog that looked more like a standard blog (i.e. my blog)?

I’d love to hear opinions from social media experts as well as personal thoughts/feelings from blog readers.

Related posts:

  1. Online Community, A Case Study: WithoutWax.tv
  2. Need Any Design Work Done?
Posted at 1:44 PM on February 6th, 2009
  • Kacey

    In my experience, readers are more likely to comment and engage on blogs that shift away from the corporate look, feel and voice. If you give me a couple weeks, I will actually have some interesting social media stats I would be glad to share with you — because that is the geek that I am ;-)

  • http://willfjohnston.com Will Johnston

    Thanks Kacey, I would be very interested in those! Would you characterize NCC’s site as having the corporate look/feel/voice or not?

  • http://www.michaelrobison.tv Michael Robison

    Bro…I think the design/style will determine people’s initial desire to see your site. But, only sheer content will determine the responses you get and the number of them you receive. Guys who tend to focus on introspective thought and personal development tend to get good response. Or, entries that evoke lots of emotion. Style’s good, content is better. Goes back to the old saying, “It’s what’s on the inside that counts!”

More in Tech
The Cons of Social Networking?

Earlier today Ed Stetzer, the President of Lifeway Research, wrote a blog post entitled "The Pros and Cons of Social...

Close